Talk:Angie Yonaga

I think I know who's Angie's English VA. Someone posted a twitter comment complimenting Cassandra, somehow including Angie Yonaga, and Cassandra gave it a like. Does that mean Aoi's VA voiced as Angie? (https://twitter.com/yamiprod/status/1147647504701382661)

Sayakiri8 (talk) 19:41, May 10, 2020 (UTC)


 * Unfortunately, because there are other characters present in this tweet you provided, we cannot accept this source. JohnnyTron190 (talk) 21:25, May 10, 2020 (UTC)


 * Cassandra has tweeted about being in a Live online event hosted by Colorworld Books. The accompanying picture only includes 8 characters (Angie included), and it's worth noting that Morris didn't just stick to replying or retweeting the posts made by @colorworldbooks; she made her own tweet, and added that picture herself. Is this substantial? HubStyle (talk) 23:16, 30 October 2020 (UTC)


 * While the tweet was made by her, the actual picture itself was made by the con, so it'd be hard to validate it. She also hasn't responded to any of the replies specifically pertaining to Angie, while at the same time responding to almost every other reply. With that, it's hard to say it is substantial Nebularman (talk) 23:52, 30 October 2020 (UTC)


 * I don't think it's hard to validate. By mentioning that the actual picture is made by the con, you're making a compelling statement towards the idea that Cassandra voiced Angie. From the other examples of VAs and accompanying characters, it would appear that all these characters were indeed voiced by the respective actors in each photo. Hence, there was most certainly a conscious decision between Cassandra and the con to include Angie in Cassandra's promo (seeing how Angie's inclusion was up there on the con's website, and the fact that Cassandra herself tweeted the promo with the character in it). I think it's rather unreasonable to say that - given the other VA promos - you would conclude that the reason why Angie is part of Cassandra's promo is still unknown, especially when the link between Angie and Cassandra has been speculated for years. I would say that the tweet is highly substantial.


 * Otherwise, I would like to know how the current Fandom source for Rantaro Amami being voiced by Johhny Yong Bosch is substantial: It's a YouTube video of a Q&A panel with JYB, and his answer to the question of whether he voiced Rantaro was (in exact quotes) "I think it's Adam Park. I think Adam Park did that role." I'm not saying this with the impression that he didn't voice Rantaro, but if that tweet is "not substantial", neither should that YouTube video. Excusememoi (talk) 06:50, 4 November 2020 (UTC)


 * "Adam Park" is a fictional character that was specifically played by JYB, and one of his more famous roles. It was his way to more or less confirm without directly stating he voiced Rantaro, likely bc of contract. Cassandra Lee Morris tweeting out an image of several characters, and not at all interacting with any that ask/mention if she's Angie, is not on par with the video. Monollama (talk)


 * Ok, let me reword what you said, now regarding Cassandra: Aoi Asahina, Taiga Aisaka, Kyubey, Kota Izumi, Ritsu Tainaka, Morgana, and Leafa are fictional characters all voiced by Cassandra in their official English dubs. It (the inclusion of Angie among the characters I listed in the promo) was her way to more or less confirm without directly stating she voiced Angie, likely bc of contract. Cassandra Lee Morris tweeting out an image of several highly relevant characters, and not at all interacting with any that ask/mention if she's Angie (maybe bc of contract, but mostly because she replied to only three comments in that tweet, so your point doesn't even stand) is at least on par with the video. Excusememoi (talk) 18:49, 4 November 2020 (UTC)


 * The mod team have discussed it, and the answer is still the tweet is not viable. Monollama (talk)


 * Understandable. There is no debating with a mod team judgment, one that dismisses a series of constructive discourse with counterarguments, analysis of multiple circumstantial sources, and analogies to a simple "still the tweet is not viable." I have gained some insight. Excusememoi (talk) 23:43, 4 November 2020 (UTC)